Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Opera: Maria Stuarda

What a waste of huge talents

Royal Opera House, London WC2

    Joyce DiDonato (left)
    Joyce DiDonato (left)

    What is opera? One thing it isn't - or shouldn't be - is a parade of singers warbling for the sake of warbling. There is a long tradition of such productions - to wit, the regular vehicles staged for Dame Joan Sutherland to show off her vocal talents - that are more often than not hack works that would never deserve to be revived in any other context.

    The ROH's production of Donizetti's Maria Stuarda falls into that category. It's a third-rate piece that is dramatically and vocally dull but has some supposed show-stoppers for singers of the calibre of Joyce DiDonato, who is in the title role. There's no other reason why it should be staged.

    I'd previously thought I'd be happy to hear Ms DiDonato sing the phone-book. But this performance showed that's not true, glorious singer and actress though she is. This is a waste of some huge talents and a dull evening - even with the wonderful Joyce DiDonato.

Music

She's 90, but the music keeps playing

Anonymous

She's 90, but the music keeps playing
Music

A triumph of Dylanology

Bryan Cheyette

A triumph of Dylanology
Music

The classical star inspired by astrology

Rosa Doherty

The classical star inspired by astrology
Music

The family who are always in harmony

Jessica Duchen

The family who are always in harmony
Music

Be in no doubt: Bob Dylan changed literature

Stoddard Martin

Be in no doubt: Bob Dylan changed literature
Music

Craig's bid for a serious comeback

Elisa Bray

Craig's bid for a serious comeback
Music

Barry Kosky: A kangaroo with a nose for opera

Jessica Duchen

Barry Kosky: A kangaroo with a nose for opera
Music

Crossing borders in music and life

Jessica Duchen

Crossing borders in music and life
Music

Sophie finds her voice - in Russia

Joseph Finlay

Sophie finds her voice - in Russia