closeicon

Lee Harpin

This is what happens when John McDonnell attacks you on Twitter

JC political editor Lee Harpin responds to the shadow chancellor who attacked him for reporting a senior Labour source's views on him

articlemain
July 02, 2019 15:29

John McDonnell has a lengthy history of making controversial statements. He once claimed peace in Ireland was “due to the IRA.” 

In a response to George Osborne’s Spending Review statement, Labour’s shadow chancellor also thought it appropriate to pull out Chairman Mao’s Little Red Book and quote from it.

He once also called student rioters, including one who threw a fire extinguisher at police from a great height, “the best of our movement”.

For a man with such a record, it came as some surprise to see him react how he did to a tweet I posted last weekend reflecting the observations of a “senior Labour source” I had spoken with on Friday.

I tweeted how the source told me Mr McDonnell was "deliberately moving away" from Mr Corbyn on policy issues, including Brexit, "because he knows leader's days are numbered".

On Sunday morning, the man himself responded: "You know this isn’t true. Let’s test this invented story. Name your so called “senior Labour source.”

“You won’t and can’t because this is just another farcical attempt to sow division & seek to undermine Labour as we challenge for power. You’ll fail as always.”

What bothers me about his actions is not his claim that what my source had told me wasn’t true. After all, only days earlier, he had himself described Labour’s lack of clarity, under Mr Corbyn, over its policy towards Brexit as a “slow-motion car crash.”

Nor is it the shadow chancellor’s futile request for me to name my source. Even he, with his background steeped in neo-Marxist theory, would recognise that democracy would not function if journalism worked like that.

What I do find alarming is how such a senior Labour figure could write the tweet that he did – knowing full well exactly what sort of crowd that his message would strike a chord with.

If John McDonnell, busy man that he is, does not have the time now to delve through the thousands of tweets I have received as a result of his response to mine, I thought I’d share some examples.

Take this one from a man who previously stood himself as a Labour councillor but resigned after endorsing an antisemitic trope about the Rothschilds.

Or this:

Or this:

I could go on and on, John McDonnell. But I won't.

Only to say, that these are the people you inspire. And for that reason alone, yes, I do want you to fail.

July 02, 2019 15:29

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive