Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Dysch on Politics: A Jewish MP reviled by the Jewish community

'Ultimately, it was a career which should have ended in disgrace with Sir Gerald’s perhaps most outrageous words two years ago'

    Sir Gerald with Yasir Arafat in 1996
    Sir Gerald with Yasir Arafat in 1996

    How different things might have been.

    Under other circumstances, this week’s JC would have been packed with tributes to the country’s oldest, and longest-serving, Jewish MP.

    We might have lauded Sir Gerald Kaufman’s admirable longevity, praised his efforts in the House of Commons over more than 45 years on behalf of fellow Jews and joked about his quirky dress sense.

    He could have been a hero of British Jewry, an influential figure loved across religious and party divides.

    Instead, Sir Gerald was reviled. The Jewish community’s responses to his death on Sunday at the age of 86 have been at best muted, but mostly silent.

    Fellow Labour MPs were gushing in their praise, his controversies seemingly scrubbed from history. Many of them referred to him being “searingly sharp”; plenty said he was “funny”, “kind” and a good friend.

    This for a man who racially abused a Jewish colleague on the Labour benches, and who promoted antisemitic tropes that his party leader claims he wants to fight “with every breath”.

    For years, Sir Gerald had been a bête noire of the community – a prominent Jew who spoke out repeatedly against Israel, calling for an arms embargo, sanctions and boycotts at least a decade before such a position became fashionable.

    A 2002 BBC documentary, broadcast on Rosh Hashanah, in which he travelled to Israel to record his complaints about the country, was called The End of An Affair and supposed to mark his final engagement with the topic.

    But he could not stop. His continued comments resulted in him being verbally abused at his local synagogue and confirmed his persona non grata position in the community.

    Little could anyone have imagined he would sink lower almost a decade later. Criticising Israel is one thing, but it was his full-blown antisemitism that was truly beyond the pale. He compared Israeli soldiers serving during the Gaza conflict of 2009 to the Nazis who forced his ancestors to flee Poland.

    His “here we are, the Jews again” comment when Labour MP Louise Ellman rose to speak in the chamber in 2011 was not just crass, but specifically targeted, knowingly full well the hurt that would – and did – follow.

    Ultimately, it was a career which should have ended in disgrace with Sir Gerald’s perhaps most outrageous words two years ago. First, he claimed Israel used the Holocaust to justify murdering Palestinians, before later claiming “Jewish money” influenced the Conservative government.

    Neither of his claims brought disciplinary action, merely a slap on the wrist from Mr Corbyn for the latter allegation.

    I last saw Sir Gerald in November 2015 when I went to ask him about those views on “Jewish money”. I found him apparently asleep in his office, and, after waking him, his only response was to tell me to “go away”. He would not, he added, be explaining himself to JC readers. Defiant to the last.

    A son of immigrants to West Yorkshire, an apparent outsider who became a fixture of the political classes — what an example Gerald Kaufman could have set; what a legacy he could have left. How different things might have been.

Columnists

Labour's battle in Brighton

Marcus Dysch

Wednesday, September 20, 2017

Labour's battle in Brighton
UK News

Jeremy Corbyn's Rosh Hashanah message

Marcus Dysch

Tuesday, September 19, 2017

Jeremy Corbyn's Rosh Hashanah message
UK News

Theresa May's Rosh Hashanah reception

Marcus Dysch

Wednesday, September 13, 2017

Theresa May's Rosh Hashanah reception
News Features

Interview: Joan Ryan

Marcus Dysch

Wednesday, September 20, 2017

Interview: Joan Ryan
UK News

‘Stand-out’ conference for Lib Dems

Marcus Dysch

Tuesday, September 19, 2017

‘Stand-out’ conference for Lib Dems
UK News

Report shines light on antisemitism in the UK

Marcus Dysch

Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Report shines light on antisemitism in the UK
UK News

Board seeks views for election manifesto

Marcus Dysch

Tuesday, September 19, 2017

Board seeks views for election manifesto
Columnists

Now even Sir Vince says he is our friend

Marcus Dysch

Thursday, September 14, 2017

Now even Sir Vince says he is our friend
UK News

Race to restore art looted by the Nazis

Marcus Dysch

Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Race to restore art looted by the Nazis