Alex Brummer

Media blind to nature of Chabad horror

By Alex Brummer, December 4, 2008

The argument made in some quarters that a distinction can be drawn between anti-Zionism and antisemitism looks threadbare after the attack on the Chabad house in Mumbai. The Jewish centre may have provided a refuge to Israeli travellers passing through India’s commercial centre, but it was an outpost of traditional Judaism — not Israel.

As far as the terrorists are concerned, Jews and Zionists are one and the same. The inherent racism in what happened in Mumbai, where the targets were Westerners and Jews, was largely missed by the British media.


Rare insight into the chaos that is Gaza

By Alex Brummer, November 27, 2008

A key reason for the poor perception of Israel in Britain is the way events in Gaza are reported. Israel is generally depicted as the nasty jailer responsible for what is often described as the "world's biggest prison".

Admittedly, Israel's tough policy towards Gaza does not help. It was only in the past week that Jerusalem relaxed a 19-day blockade of the Hamas-controlled territory to admit humanitarian assistance.


Kosher ‘Rahmbo’ triggers a press storm

By Alex Brummer, November 13, 2008

The politically safest White House chiefs of staff have tended to be those who manage to stay out of the headlines. That will prove extraordinarily difficult for Rahm "Rahmbo" Emanuel, the first anointed member of the Barack Obama administration. He already has attracted press attention on both sides of the Atlantic - and not all of it favourable.


Will BBC now tighten Mid-East reporting?

By Alex Brummer, November 6, 2008

It is possible that the Ross-Brand affair may come to be seen as a tipping point for the BBC. It provided a sharp reminder that despite its "public service" remit and £3 billion-a-year subvention from the taxpayer, the corporation is a behemoth that has become extremely difficult to control.

The director-general, Mark Thompson, may glorify in the title of editor-in-chief, but he now runs a media organisation where it is almost impossible for Reithian standards to be upheld across all platforms.


Obama and Livni are cast as saviours

By Alex Brummer, October 30, 2008

As the American presidential election reaches its climax, US politics dominate the media. The only other foreign story to get much of a look-in has been the failure of the Kadima party leader Tzipi Livni to forge a governing coalition in Israel after boldly refusing to give in to what The Times called the "blackmail" of the small, strictly Orthodox parties.


Akko riots get buried by credit crunch

By Alex Brummer, October 23, 2008


Critics lap up the Tom Hurndall film…

By Alex Brummer, October 17, 2008

The IDF's shooting of 21-year-old Tom Hurndall, a volunteer for the International Solidarity Movement, in April 2003 was a tragic mistake for which its reputation has suffered dearly. As a result of the tenacious campaign by the Hurndall family, the soldier responsible, Taysir Hayb, is serving eight years for manslaughter. A British inquest found that Hurndall had been "intentionally killed" and delivered a verdict of "unlawful killing".


Comment is free, but it can go too far

By Alex Brummer, October 10, 2008

Media websites have a duty to make sure they do not turn into forums for hate

One of the great challenges for newspapers with widely used websites is how to police the comments by readers. Each publication has its own rules. The Guardian's Comment is Free website aims to take down unacceptable material as soon as possible after it is posted. The Jerusalem Post has a policy of pre-vetting material using a team of monitors.


Papers are too quick to accept NGO reports

By Alex Brummer, October 3, 2008

Why do the media back claims by non-governmental organisations with their own agendas?

Few regions in the world are as closely monitored by non-governmental organisations (NGOs) as Israel and the Palestinian territories. Almost every aspect of Israel's behaviour comes under scrutiny, from the medical care for Palestinians seeking treatment in Israel to food supplies in Gaza and the peace process.
The presence of so many such groups in the region is a compliment to the pluralism of Israeli democracy.


Livni, the ‘spy’ who seduced the press

By Alex Brummer, September 26, 2008

The new Kadima leader has received plenty of positive coverage, thanks to her gender and Mossad past

Amid headlines dominated by the meltdown of global banking, few other international stories have caught the imagination of Britain's notoriously fickle press in recent days. Among the small band of exceptions was the story of the narrow victory of Tzipi Livni in the Kadima leadership election, which is likely to result in her becoming Israel's second female prime minister.


Fine journalism as a paper hunts for Shalit

By Alex Brummer, September 19, 2008

The Sunday Times goes to Gaza to ‘find' Israel's kidnapped soldier

The kidnapping of 19-year-old Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit on June 25, 2006 at the Israel-Gaza border was one of the seminal events in recent Middle East history, marking a new stage of the conflict between
Israel and Islamic-backed militias.


London Review of Books looks anti-Israel

By Alex Brummer, September 12, 2008

The LRB dropped a Middle East-related review at the last minute. Why?


The London Review of Books is no stranger to controversy. Two years ago the paper's editor, Mary-Kay Wilmers, found herself at the centre of a firestorm when it published a searing article by the academics John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt claiming that the Israel lobby in the United States holds a disproportionate sway over America's foreign policy.


A weakened regional press should worry us

By Alex Brummer, September 4, 2008

As smaller papers shed resources, openings for pro-Palestinian activists increase.


Britain's regional press is in dire straits. The circulation of morning titles is in freefall; the Birmingham Post's, for example, has declined 51 per cent since 1989. Circulation of other titles including the Leicester Mercury, the Northern Echo and the Argus in Brighton - an evening paper - have also been devastated. Weekly titles disappear on a regular basis.


Israel foiled the ‘Free Gaza’ stunt. At a cost

By Alex Brummer, August 28, 2008

Israel avoided a PR disaster by letting activists sail to Gaza - but there may be a grave political fallout.

If activists from the International Solidarity Movement were hoping for a media
splash when two vessels ran the Israeli sea blockade of Gaza last weekend, they will have been disappointed.


Let Middle East press monitors multiply

By Alex Brummer, August 21, 2008

Over the last decade, there has been huge concern in Anglo-Jewry and beyond about perceived bias against Israel in the Western media.

Informal groups have sprung up which seek to combat mistakes and prejudice through email and letter-writing campaigns aimed at the journalists and media outlets involved.


Jemima Khan rediscovers her Jewishness

By Alex Brummer, August 15, 2008

A convert to Islam, and former critic of Israel, has come to terms with her ancestry

Jemima Khan (née Goldsmith) is not someone known for attachment to her Jewish heritage. Indeed, at the peak of her flirtation with Islam, at the height of the intifada, she came close to buying into antisemitic theory.

Writing in The Guardian, she attributed perceived one-sided media coverage of the Israel-Palestine conflict to the fact that the Israel lobby in the US "is rich and powerful".


Papers give Olmert a moment of grace

By Alex Brummer, August 8, 2008

The Israeli PM's ‘resignation' was followed by some good press - for once

The premiership of Ehud Olmert could hardly be described as a golden period for Israel. The Kadima leader presided over the heavily criticised Lebanon campaign, saw his approval fall to the lowest level of any leader in Israel's history and became embroiled in corruption allegations. He looked a perfect example of Enoch Powell's maxim that "all political careers end in failure".


Hizbollah did not get its propaganda coup

By Alex Brummer, July 25, 2008

The images of the POW exchange reflected well on Israel in the foreign media

The media always find it difficult to deal with Israel-Arab prisoner exchanges. The sheer imbalance in numbers is hard enough to understand.

Over the last three decades, Israel has released some 7,000 Arab prisoners to secure the freedom of 19 Israelis and to retrieve the bodies of eight others.


Cartoonists have crossed the line on Israel

By Alex Brummer, July 18, 2008

In the stand-off with Iran, the Jewish state is being depicted as the aggressor — in pictures, at least

Political cartoonists skewer, amuse and give their take on issues of the day, all at the same time.Their ability to cause mayhem was underlined this week when a New Yorker cover by artist Barry Blitt, depicting Barack and Michelle Obama as Muslim and gun-toting terrorists, roused the ire of the Democratic presidential candidate.


Now proof that the Nakba narrative rules

By Alex Brummer, July 11, 2008

An analysis of the coverage of Israel’s 60th shows that the Palestinian view dominates

There has long been a need for authoritative monitoring of Israel coverage by British media outlets. Just Journalism (JJ), headed by Middle East commentator Adel Darwish, seeks to do this with quantitative and content analysis. The group’s first major study, looking at UK media coverage of Israel’s 60th birthday, reinforces many of the stereotypes held by British Jewry.