Correcting my vision in Palestine

The prospect of taking part in a Palestinian literary festival was scary. The reality was shaming.


By Adam Foulds, June 3, 2010
Follow The JC on Twitter

A few weeks ago, I stood by Abraham's tomb in Hebron during the recitation of the Amidah.

It was an awesome moment, to be at the resting place of the first Jew on earth while hearing the liturgy, and it came at the end of an extraordinary journey, one that had challenged the assumptions I had set out with. My journey was through Palestine. I was travelling with a literary festival.

The invitation had immediately appealed. The Palestine situation is so much at the centre of contemporary Jewish life that I was keen to see it for myself. I was nervous, of course. All the voices of my education, all the years of news footage - charred car bodies, masked gunmen, wailing crowds, photographers pushed back as stretchers are rushed into ambulances - told me to be scared.

The first revelation of the trip changed that. It was so obvious, so bound to be true, that I'm almost ashamed to admit what it was: Palestinians are normal people. Unlike the turbulent, vengeful individuals I had been expecting, I encountered warm, rational, intelligent human beings, concerned for their families and struggling with a difficult situation.

Moreover, I personally didn't encounter a whiff of antisemitism. People spoke about the settlers or the army, never about "the Jews." In fact, to my great surprise, some spoke about missing living together with Jews. In many places, Jerusalem and Bethlehem, for example, that had been the situation for centuries. To get over the invisible barrier of fear and find real people, great hospitality and humanity, was a wonderful discovery, one that filled me with hope. But increasingly over the following days what I was seeing caused anguish.

The great benefit of being there yourself is that it releases you from the endless to-and-fro of argument about the situation. You can see what is happening, the facts on the ground, facts that can't be contradicted by any argument from either side. What you see is that there are a huge number of illegal settlements within Palestinian territory and that the wall is in the wrong place.

The settlements are shocking in their scale. They are easy to spot because they are always on the tops of hills and are reinforced. Some, like those in a ring around Nablus, are so far into territory necessary and promised for a viable Palestinian state as to make that future seem impossible.

What can be done with these armed fundamentalist inhabitants who would rather kill than move? Settler Judaism is hard for me to comprehend. It seems to lack all the moral and intellectual depth, the subtlety and sensitivity, of the Judaism I am proud to have grown up in. Full of messianic fervour, indifferent to pain, soaked in violence, it privileges the one commandment to settle over the other six hundred and twelve. That they have been tolerated and supported in pursuing this activity, which seriously damages the chances of a two-state solution, is mystifying to me.

In Bethlehem, you see the placement of the wall. Nine metres high it rises just beyond the last house, wrapped so tightly around the little town, severing it from the landscape, that natural population growth can be expected to produce extreme overcrowding. At certain points you can see over the wall to olive groves that formerly supported a large number of Bethlehemites and that now they can't reach. An Israeli law states that land "abandoned" for seven years becomes state property. Trapped inside the wall, they wait for this to happen.

If the security rationale for the wall was the only one, it would be in a different place, running along the green line, and it would be continuous. It remains possible to get around the wall. Impoverished Palestinian labourers do this regularly to find manual work within Israel. Standing there, seeing where it is, it is plain that the construction of the wall has been in part a land-grab.

Seeing, too, the frightening checkpoints, and Hebron settlements built directly over the remaining Palestinians in the old city, over whom rubbish and urine are thrown down, I came away with a new understanding of why so many Jews within Israel and the diaspora are protesting against current Israeli government policies. For myself, the words of William Blake came to mind: opposition is true friendship.

Adam Foulds's novel 'The Quickening Maze' was nominated for the 2009 Man Booker Prize

    Last updated: 2:24pm, August 13 2010

    COMMENTS

    Advis3r

    Tue, 06/08/2010 - 07:14

    Rate this:

    0 points

    I do not beleive for one moment your vision of "Palestine" ever needed correcting. First you were not travelling through Palestine but Judea and Samaria. As a Jew why do you consider you have to compromise on your heritage? jews have been contionuously living here for over 3000 years.Your use of the word "shocking" when describing the building of Jewish communities in our ancient homeland (which you admit in your second paragraph) foretells the course this dreadful report is to take. The building of Jewish homes in Judea and Samaria may be disputed but is not illegal the Arabs repeat the lie again and again and useful idiots believe it. Did you ever spend time with the "fundamentalists" to get their point of view I can assure in 99.9% of cases you will find warm, rational, intelligent human beings, concerned for their families and struggling with a difficult situation? You say Arabs miss living with Jews that is why they massacred them in Hebron in 1929 and bomb our buses and rocket our cities. That's why the barrier (not wall) is there - the epithet "land grab" is taken straight out of Arab/extreme leftist propaganda which you continuously parrot. Be frank your vision was in no need of correction sadly all that happened was that your myopia was further intensified.


    tomeisner2

    Tue, 06/08/2010 - 12:43

    Rate this:

    0 points

    Congratulations Adam. and Advis3r please enter the 21st century and stop spouting this fairy tale nonsense about Judea and Samaria. it really sounds like something out of Lord of the Rings, I mean why not call it Middle Earth?
    It is called, yes you can say it PALESTINE!!


    Advis3r

    Tue, 06/08/2010 - 13:18

    Rate this:

    -1 points

    Tomeisner2/Adam Foulds birds of a feather.

    I suggest you look at any reputable geographical map and you will see that Mr Foulds "revelation" took place in Judea and Samaria those are the area's geographical names.

    There is now and never was a country called "Palestine" you know it but unfortunately your hatred for Israel renders you incapable of admitting the truth - what a pity. Repeating a lie however many times does not, to Goebbels regret, make it the truth


    Blacklisted Dictator

    Tue, 06/08/2010 - 13:18

    Rate this:

    0 points

    Who is directing Adam Foulds' Hollywood screenplay entitled "Opposition is true friendship" ?


    Advis3r

    Tue, 06/08/2010 - 13:50

    Rate this:

    0 points

    Here is a link to the Merrian Webster map of israel

    http://geography.about.com/gi/o.htm?zi=1/XJ/Ya&zTi=1&sdn=geography&cdn=e...

    Suggest you look at it.


    christopher

    Fri, 01/21/2011 - 16:41

    Rate this:

    0 points

    Hrmm that was weird, my comment got eaten. Anyway I wanted to say that it's nice to know that someone else also mentioned this as I had trouble finding the same info elsewhere. This was the first place that told me the answer. Thanks.
    Woodfield university

    POST A COMMENT

    You must be logged in to post a comment.