Lib Dems are only on one side: the side of peace

The blame game is the real obstacle to Middle East peace


By Lynne Featherstone, April 22, 2010
Follow The JC on Twitter

In Hornsey & Wood Green in North London, there is a strong pro-Israel lobby and a strong pro-Palestinian lobby. When Jenny Tonge made her disgraceful and ignorant comments in the JC, calling for an inquiry into Israel taking organs in Haiti, I got emails from the pro-Israel lobby saying that the Liberal Democrats were pro-Palestinian.

When Nick Clegg then rightly sacked Baroness Tonge from the front bench, I received emails claiming that he had only done so because the "Zionist conspiracy" had got to him. Both were symptomatic of the polarization by the two sides in the Middle East conflict.

The only side the Liberal Democrats are on is the side of peace. We condemn all acts of violence and urge all parties to negotiate a lasting settlement to this crisis. A sustainable solution will only be achieved with two separate Israeli and Palestinian states, mutually recognized and internationally accepted, within secure borders based on the situation before the 1967 conflict.

Liberal Democrats condemn Hamas violence unequivocally. We believe that Hamas must move to respect the "three principles" set by the Quartet: renounce violence, recognise Israel's right to exist and accept previous agreements.

Entrenched positions on both sides get us knowhere

However, we are concerned that while Hamas recognition of Israel is a necessary outcome of negotiations, it should not be interpreted so rigidly that it becomes a pre-condition that stops progress towards peace.

Searching for a solution also means swallowing some bitter pills. I hate to see the lesson that history teaches us, but the bitter truth is that dealing with unpleasant, murderous brutes is often needed to bring peace. Remember the IRA? In the end, the promise of peace and prosperity, together with negotiation, is what eventually heralded a break in the deadlock of decades and the hatred of centuries.

Entrenched positions get us nowhere. Being partisan or playing the blame is a hiding to nothing. No change, no solution.

Blame has been hurled back and forth, ricocheting between opposing sides ever since Israel's painful birth. It is the Palestinians in the refugee camps and the ordinary citizens of Israel who suffer in this terrible game.

If there is one thing that is clear to me it is that none of the players really have the best interests of these peoples at heart. It is all about agendas and interests. That applies to the US and Iran, the UK and those countries in the region, all of whom are going to have to be willing to change the game.

We need the world to roll up its sleeves and commit itself for as long as it takes to focus all its efforts on pursuing peace and a lasting settlement. Blaming those who aren't willing to do that is the only part of the blame game worth playing.

Lynne Featherstone is Liberal Democrat candidate for Hornsey and Wood Green, and the party's spokesperson on Youth and Equality issues

    Last updated: 10:49am, July 9 2010

    COMMENTS

    modernity

    25 April, 2010 - 15:04

    Rate this:

    0 points

    Baroness Tonge may have been sacked from the front bench, but she wasn't expelled.

    This is despite, years of borderline and racist comments.

    Perhaps the Lib Dems would care to explain why she hasn't been expelled?


    Jonathan Hoffman

    25 April, 2010 - 17:00

    Rate this:

    0 points

    Very worthy Lynne. Youalways sit on the fence when it comes to Israel don't you?

    But your Party doesn't sit on the fence does it ..

    The real question is: What influence has Nadhmi Auchi's Anglo-Arab Organisation had on the LibDems' Middle East policies?

    http://www.thejc.com/news/uk-news/30841/anti-israel-iraqi-billionaires-d...

    http://www.thejc.com/blogpost/libdem-policy-against-israel

    http://modernityblog.wordpress.com/2010/04/25/lib-dems-dont-upset-the-mo...

    I think we should be told Lynne


    Jonathan Hoffman

    25 April, 2010 - 21:44

    Rate this:

    0 points

    And how come Lynne that you signed EDM502 oposing closing the Universal Jurisdiction anomaly?

    One can only presume you want to see Israelis coming to the UK arrested on irrelevant pretexts.

    How does that bias square with your extremely worthy article above?


    jose (not verified)

    6 May, 2010 - 06:48

    Rate this:

    1 point

    If Lynne thinks we should negociate with Hamas (a terrorist organization vowing to destroy Israel and kill Jews, not only Israelis, all around the world), what does Lynne think of Abbas permanent refusal to negociate with Israel without conditions? And Abbas is not dealing with an Israel that has vowed destruction of "Palestine" and the genocide of Palestinians, but with one that accept the principle of two nations for two people.

    Does Lynne understand that her position on Hamas undermine Abbas' willingness to make peace with Israel? If there are no conciliatory moves to make first (such as stopping terrorist violence), why should he abstain from making himself popular by calling to war with Israel?

    Lynne cannot delude herself that the Lib Dem position is balanced on the Middle East subject just by stating that some terrorist-supporters disagree with them. They would disagree as well with all but those who are outright antisemits.

    Lynne needs to roll up her sleaves and admit that they are prejudiced against Israel and, as far as Baronness Tonge is concerned, prejudiced against Jews.


    christopher

    21 January, 2011 - 15:42

    Rate this:

    0 points

    I found your website perfect for my needs. It contains wonderful and helpful posts. Carry on this work. In the end, I would like to thank you for making such a nice website.
    Woodfield university

    POST A COMMENT

    You must be logged in to post a comment.