Your blogs

  • Thinking of Gilad Shalit

    Rabbi Aaron Gol...
    Nov 30, 2009

    There are some thoughts that might come to us when we are on our own and living in fear that could not be conceived when we are with others and feeling comfortable. Who are the secure to judge those living with insecurity?

    In our parashsa, Jacob’s isolation is one of utter fear....In this instance, I forgive Jacob his apparent bargaining with God. For in the solitude of fear, who are we to judge the prayers, the vows, the pleas of utter desperation, even the demands on God? One person who has now been in solitary confinement for 1252 days is Gilad Shalit...

    We do not know the prayers, the vows, the pleas of utter desperation, even the demands on God that Gilda Shalit has uttered these past 1252 days. I cannot conceive of his position nor hear word of theological judgement of them.

  • Response to Brian Fox

    Jonathan Hoffman
    Nov 20, 2009

    Reform Rabbi Brian Fox attacked me in the Jewish Telegraph on 6 November:

    "LIKE many others I was appalled, and even ashamed, of Jonathan Hoffman's 'contribution' in Bolton at the Octagon Theatre which was so admirably reported on by Gita Conn. I am sure that Mr Hoffman loves Israel, but so did Meir Kahane. Tony Sheldon may have been there, but he certainly was not listening. I did not say that being there was more important than the requirements of Shabbat. All the Jews who were there probably broke Shabbat just to be there. Like me they made a value judgement. What I actually said was that if there was an opportunity to have real dialogue with Palestinians I would turn up on Yom Kippur. Does that mean I do not keep Yom Kippur? Not at all. It is Shabbat Shabbaton: the greatest of all Shabbats. But dialogue with our enemy and maybe even saving lives must take precedence. Judaism makes value judgements all the time: it is permitted to sell a Torah scroll to save a Jewish day school. It is permitted to break Shabbat to save a life. We are living in dangerous times. Bullying a la Mr Hoffman and selected hearing a la Mr Sheldon will not help."
    Rabbi Brian D Fox, Menorah (Cheshire Reform) Synagogue, Sharston, Cheshire.

    The Jewish Telegraph printed my reponse today but it is not in the online version - so here it is:

  • What 'Dispatches' Tonight Won't Tell You..........

    Jonathan Hoffman
    Nov 16, 2009

    Five things I guarantee you won't learn tonight about the all-powerful 'Israel Lobby' in the UK:

    - It failed to persuade the UK to veto Goldstone in the UN
    - It failed to persuade the UK not to start an arms embargo on Israel
    - It failed to persuade the UK Foreign Minister not to call Cast Lead 'disproportionate'...
    - It failed to stop the UK financing Breaking The Silence
    - It failed to persuade most Labour MPs in 'Labour Friends of Israel' not to keep stumm when it comes to asserting Israel's right to defend its citizens....

    If this is "one of the most powerful and influential political lobbies in Britain" then my name is Yasser Arafat ....

  • Mitzvah Day: Honouring our role models

    Rabbi Aaron Gol...
    Nov 15, 2009

    When looking for role models in the Torah, one often has to look at an episode in their lives rather than take into account all the aspects of their lives. Rebecca does not come out smelling like roses, when we consider a literal interpretation of the devious and single-minded way that she favours Jacob over Esau and encourages him to con his brother out of what was rightfully his and to take advantage of his own father’s disabilities to achieve his goals.

    Yet in the episode that I have chosen this morning, Rebecca is a symbol for us all as we seek to follow God’s path of righteousness. In particular, as we honour all those who volunteer in our Community for the good of others, we find exceptional behaviour exhibited by our Matriarch.

    The medieval Biblical Commentator, Don Isaac Abravanel was himself an incredible contributor to the Jewish Community. Born in Lisbon in 1437, he served as Finance Minister to the kings of Portugal, Spain and Naples. He sought to use his position to lighten the burden on his people but personally suffered from court intrigues and was expelled with the rest of his People in 1492.

  • AJEX @ NPLS

    Rabbi Aaron Gol...
    Nov 15, 2009

    This Sunday marks the 75th Annual Remembrance Ceremony and Parade. The ex-Servicemen and women will fall in at Horse Guards Parade before marching to the Cenotaph at Whitehall for a memorial service.

    At the time of the World Wars, it must have seemed inconceivable for those who survived them, to see the year 2000, let alone 2010. Yet here in our midst today, though afflicted by time, are those who remain true to their word, never to forget their fellow men and women who fell in battle, who were seriously injured and of course all those who have kept the memory alive who have died in subsequent years. Today, the mother of one of our members died at the age of 101. Her death today brought home to me the fact that this country now no longer has the presence of vets from the First World War, and yet time has not faded our memory of the tragedy of that war, the horrendous scale of loss – historians estimate that over 20 million people were killed - nor the immense courage of those who fought in it.

    Yet what rings in my ears are the words of one of the last British veteran of the Western trenches of World War One, Harry Patch....

  • Doss vs. Chiloni: Two Sides of the Same Shekel

    Melchett Mike
    Nov 15, 2009

    "Too many dossim."

    This is the almost universal response I have received from Tel Avivim these past weeks, when I have informed them that I am considering a move to the country's capital (though many of them probably do not even consider Jerusalem as such).

    "Dossim" (singular "doss") is Hebrew slang used to refer to the ultra-Orthodox or charedim (though it can also be used, usually less pejoratively, in relation to modern Orthodox dati le'umim).

  • The X Factor - An exploitation of the naïve?

    Michael Sophocles
    Nov 12, 2009

    Having come from a reality television background, I am fully aware of being exposed to a nation thirsty for blood.

    Of course, as candidates on The Apprentice we knew what we were getting ourselves into, but being cautious is not a quality one exhibts when facing a 'life changing’ opportunity.

    The X Factor of course is a very different animal to a business show. Despite both shows being labeled under the genre of 'reality television', the nature of X Factor makes me feel altogether frustrated and even a little uneasy.