Ken means I can't back Labour

By Jessica Elgot
March 28, 2012

I'm thinking of starting a support group. Our community is full of charities and counselling services covering every cough, spit and ailment in the medical dictionary. But I think we need another.

I'd call it "I used to vote Labour, but now I don't know what to do." To those six Labour supporters who wrote a letter to Ed Miliband last week, expressing their concerns about Ken Livingstone's obsession with Israel, to the brave Jonathan Freedland, I say: "Comrades! You are not alone!" Together, I daresay we could add hundreds of signatures to that letter. Figures seem to suggest one in three Labour voters won't back Ken.

I imagine we'd sit in a semi-circle, heads in our hands, recalling how Ken campaigned for Lutfur Rahman - an independent with alleged links to the Islamic Forum of Europe - to be mayor of Tower Hamlets, rather than the Labour candidate. We'd grimace at the memory of his chumminess with controversial Islamic cleric Yusuf al-Qaradawi.

In our chilly community centre hall, sat on plastic folding chairs, we'd wear badges identifying our constituencies. Mine would probably draw some extra sympathy. I live in Islington North, the constituency of Jeremy Corbyn, the Press TV commentator who would have chaired the meeting with Palestinian leader Raed Salah at the House of Commons - had the Home Secretary not attempted to have Saleh banned from the UK.

This week I plan to return my membership card and cancel my direct debit. I joined because I wanted Labour to stay in government in 2010. I consider myself centre-left, and believe in strong social welfare policies and protecting the NHS from privatisation.

As a member, I am repeatedly asked to campaign with my MP and for Ken. And although his campaign newsletters are now going directly into my junk mail, despite everything, I had some vague notion of being able to grit my teeth and vote Labour in May.

Ken's remarks last week were not the final straw. The rub is the reaction of the party I felt a loyalty to. The letter came from loyal Labour campaigners and councillors, who were worried about the man their party had picked to represent them.

Can it really be true that nobody in the campaign HQ finds it troubling that Ken believes that all Jews vote Conservative, and that "Jew", "Israeli" and "Zionist" can be used interchangeably?

This is not an attempt to smear Ken or the party in order to rally support for his opponent. But my concerns have been dismissed as irrelevant, or as "electioneering" against him. It is one small mercy that nobody has dared use the word "conspiracy" yet.

I have written three times to Ed Miliband and other party leaders in a personal capacity. In July, I expressed my concern about my MP's jaunt to Beirut, for Viva Palestina's Summer University, alongside Palestinian hijacker Leila Khaled, and Azzam Tamimi, who has spoken of his desire to become a suicide bomber. No response.

I emailed expressing my alarm at Ken's backing for Rahman. No response. And having been invited to a fundraising night for Ken at the "Shadow Lounge", I wrote that he should spend less time there and more time working out how large his cheque to HMRC should be. No response.

The account given by the Jewish Labour supporters suggests that what Ken is doing is brushing off the concerns of even of his most loyal supporters, and attempting to define us not only as rich Tories, but as just a "religion", not a culture, ethnicity or a people.

This mayoral election will be the first election I do not vote Labour. If Corbyn stands in the next election in Islington North, I will not vote Labour then either. It is sad that it is the people, and not the policies, which have driven so many Jewish voters away.


Real Real Zionist

Thu, 03/29/2012 - 10:27

Rate this:

0 points

Livingstone is a nauseating carpet bagger.I was pleased when he won the first mayoral election but only because it pissed Tony Bliar off. Boris is a ludicrous Hooray Henry buffoon. He went to skool with Hoffman and has dubious links to Coleman so maybe it's not all his fault.

Jessica you should try not voting, it is very therapeutic.

You at least will be able to say don't blame me I didn't encourage them.

Mary in Brighton

Thu, 03/29/2012 - 12:20

Rate this:

0 points

What does "voting" mean?


Thu, 03/29/2012 - 14:16

Rate this:

0 points

I am surprised you asked that question 'cos it's what socialists do - early and often.


Fri, 03/30/2012 - 09:29

Rate this:

0 points

Real Real Zionist

Fri, 03/30/2012 - 11:40

Rate this:

0 points

And now we have him wanting to move on from the "Ken and the Jews" drama.

Who among us would want to move on from an issue over which we were winning and was to our benefit?

Who among us would not wish to move on from an issue which we were overwhelming losing and which was to our detriment given an election was just around the corner ?

While I am no fan of Martin Bright who is just as much a carpet bagger as cuddly Ken, on this occasion he gets it spot on.

If you are one of those inexplicable people that just can't help themselves and just HAS to vote ( sigh ), vote Boris.

Boris may be a hopeless corrupt oaf but at least there is no danger of misunderstanding exactly where he is coming from.


Fri, 03/30/2012 - 12:52

Rate this:

0 points

Jessica - your entire polemic against Labour is because some Labour supporters, MPs , candidates support justice for Palestinians.
Well there are also many non Labour voters / candidates / MPs who support an end to the occupation and apartheid in the occupied territories and justice for Palestinians.


You must be logged in to post a comment.