Maybe next time?

By Advis3r
April 1, 2011

Dear Friends,

Below find out what happened to famous Israeli journalist Kalman Libskind after his car was stoned by Arabs, no, not in Judea or Samaria but rather in Gimzu, not far from Rehovot. The title of his article was; "Attacked by Arabs? Don't turn to the police for help!"

To us, who some call toxic settlers the story did not come as a surprise. We know that the police will always prefer to believe the Arabs' version of events rather than the Jews' and how often did we not find ourselves accused of crimes we never committed, with the police inventing all kind of stories about us. The good thing is that this time it happened to a Maariv journalist and he managed to publish his story far and wide.

Shabbat Shalom,

Israeli Reporter's Car Stoning has Kafkaesque Aftermath by Arutz7 Staff

Well-known Israeli investigative reporter for the Maariv Hebrew daily, Kalman Liebskind, had a Kafkaesque story to report this week, and the subject of the article was himself.

"Driving down the road that leads to our home in Gimzu, I heard the first bang", he wrote in Hebrew in his weekly column. " My wife, Ilana, who was driving behind me with some of our children, had gotten a direct hit to the front window of her car. By some miracle, the window didn't shatter, but the rock hit the part of the window that was a little over a foot from my son's head. I could hardly believe it was true. Rocks? On our road? An asteroid hitting us seemed more probable than rock throwing 100 yards from our home."

Gimzu is a middle class, religious Zionist suburban community (moshav) located near the cities of Modiin and Lod, not in Judea or Samaria.

He continues: "Everyone piled into my car and we drove out of the community. The instant we reached the place where the rocks had been thrown, we heard another bang. This time the rock hit the front fender, and this time we saw who was throwing the rocks, a youth who looked around 18 and was standing about 3 yards away. He ran off with an accomplice into the wooded area nearby. We discovered only later that two other women had had rocks thrown at them shortly beforehand."

Liebeskind and his neighbors called the police, who took some time to reach the community, but then went out to the wooded area with them to search for the rock throwers. They came upon a campfire with about 20 Israeli Arab young men from Lod and their bearded teachers or counselors wearing Muslim dress and headgear. "If we want to, we can burn all of Gimzu" said one of them to the shocked Israeli Jews.

The Arabs informed the police that they had left a mosque in Lod after hearing a lecture on the Koran and continued on their way to make a campfire. They had vandalized the woods by spraying the trees with Arabic words. "The police did not question anyone and only arrested the rock thrower whom we could identify," LIebeskind wrote.

Later in the week, Liebeskind received a call from the Lod Police Department asking him to come in to help complete the investigation of the incident. To his astonishment, within a short time of arriving there, he found himself being accused formally, under "suspicion of threatening the Arabs with a weapon" and heard an officer tell him "you don't have to respond. Anything you say may be used against you."

"Where did this ridiculous idea come from?" he asked the police officers. It turned out that the Arab who had thrown the stones and his friends had filed a complaint claiming that Liebeskind threatened them. The journalist suggested asking 50 people in Gimzu to serve as character witnesses for him. "That's useless, they will be your friends and not objective," was the response. "And these Arabs who threw stones at me and know that I filed a complaint against them are objective?" he rejoined. To no avail. After an hour of questioning, he found himself measured, photographed, fingerprinted and freed under personal recognizance.

Humiliated, the journalist described himself as shocked by the possibility that the police might believe the offender's version of what had occurred to him.

He had found himself in a situation that has happened often to residents of Judea and Samaria, who often find themselves falsely accused in the mainstream media, including the newspapers (including the JC blog site), of crimes perpetrated by Arabs, from stealing and destroying olive trees to burning sheep and throwing rocks. Hopefully next time you will think twice before rushing to condemn us.


Joe Millis

Fri, 04/01/2011 - 13:33

Rate this:

0 points

The Israeli Police aren't very good, are they? It's just like those four Palestinians who were wrongly accused of rape by a Bnei Brak boy. They were treated like sub-humans until the kid confessed to having made up the story.

Allan Bloom

Fri, 04/01/2011 - 14:48

Rate this:

0 points

Which all goes to highlight the absurdity, prevalent on this site, of presenting as " proof " some anecdote or some generalisation from some particular. Where is Jose by the way ?


You must be logged in to post a comment.