ZF Condemns TUC Boycott Motion


By Jonathan Hoffman
September 15, 2010
Share

Zionist Federation condemns TUC Congress approval of discriminatory boycott of Israeli goods

The ZF totally condemns the British Trade Union Congress' approval of a discriminatory boycott of Israeli goods, yesterday.

Jonathan Sacerdoti, Director of Public Affairs of the Zionist Federation, said "the TUC Congress calls for an immediate end to the military blockade on Gaza . This can only happen when there is no remaining threat of terrorist rocket attacks emanating from the Gaza strip. Rockets are currently still being launched towards Israeli civilian areas. In recent months Israel lifted many of the restrictions on what is allowed to pass into the Gaza strip, but it remains clear to all who are open minded enough to see it that until a better method for ensuring Israel's security from terrorist attacks exists, restrictions must stay in place. This is simply common sense.

"The TUC should concentrate on representing the interests of its members at a time when cuts are affecting ever more of them. There is no legitimate reason for the TUC to be targeting Israel (and no other country in the world) according the dubious desires of a group of its members who take few (if any) proactive actions to foster peace in the Middle East . The PSC continually seeks to hijack Trade Unions to promote their anti-Israel and anti-peace agenda. It is a divisive and disruptive organization.“

The ZF encourages its supporters to fight back, by getting involved in Trade Unions and speaking out as well as buying Israeli goods. We call on trade union members to protest to their union executives and we call for increased cooperation between the TUC and the Histadrut, for the benefit of peace in the interests of both Palestinian and Israeli workers.

Israel remains committed to the existence of two states: one for the Jewish people and one for the Palestinian people. To that end, negotiations are underway between Israel and the Palestinian Authority. Israel has repeatedly demonstrated its commitment to a secure two state solution.

Note on TUC's actions:

The TUC Congress claims to be concerned for the welfare of Palestinians, yet made no mention of the Jordanian government's failure to provide refugees of the 1948 war with basic human rights such as citizenship and voting. Nor did they condemn Lebanon for its refusal to allow Palestinian refugees the right to work or vote. They issued no condemnation of Syria for its terrible treatment of Palestinians in its care, no condemnation of Hamas for its continued assault on the freedoms of residents of Gaza including the burning of UNRWA children's camps, human trafficking, regular executions and use of torture, and the continued murders of Israeli civilians. Furthermore, the TUC issued no condemnation of Iran for its systematic use of rape and torture of political dissidents, executions by stoning, or persecution of homosexuals and women. Nor did they condemn Yemen for its brutal and deadly attacks against civilians in the north (with Saudi collusion).

In fact, the TUC Congress issued no condemnations of anyone apart from Israel , the one country in the region that shares Western values and constantly strives to improve itself and the lives of its citizens and workers.

Notes on boycotts:

- A boycott will not help to bring peace to the region. Boycotts are divisive and deliberately discriminatory. Those truly interested in promoting and encouraging peace in Israel and the Middle East concentrate on cooperation, not on strengthening and creating divisions.

- A boycott harms everyone: Palestinian workers will suffer directly as a result of any boycott, as many rely on Israel for work. The Palestinian economy is growing rapidly in a challenging global climate, largely owing to collaborative efforts involving Israel to improve the lives of Palestinians. The UK may also suffer increased isolation and counter-boycott from countries who recognise the negative and counter-productive nature of anti-Israel actions such as this boycott. Of course, such a boycott is directly intended to damage Israel , for no constructive reason.

Notes on settlements:

- The TUC statement contains numerous factual inaccuracies and distortions. There is no legal decision on the status of the settlements so they cannot be termed ‘illegal’. The US government for one does not hold that they are illegal. The territories of Judea and Samaria (West Bank) are disputed, and their status can only be practically determined as part of direct negotiations between the Palestinians and Israel . Boycotts here or anywhere else in the world will not assist in creating a workable and fair solution.

Media contact:

Jonathan Sacerdoti, Director of Public Affairs

tel: 07970 718 173

e: jonathan@zfuk.org

COMMENTS

zair

15 September, 2010 - 13:00

Rate this:

-1 points

Only by paying a price for occupation will Israeli's sit up and listen. BDS is a necessary part of this.


mattpryor

15 September, 2010 - 13:29

Rate this:

1 point

Boycotts have the reverse affect. They just piss people off and discourage them from listening to you.

If the PSC loved Palestinians so much they would be fighting for their rights in Jordan, Lebanon and Syria (but of course they won't do that because they are authoritarian regimes and the PSC are cowards). They would be seeking constructive cooperation with the Israeli government to improve the lives of ordinary Palestinians instead of berating ordinary businesses and families.

This boycott is counter-productive and will cause more ill feeling and deepen the conflict. Instead of supporting peace and reconciliation you are turning Britain into Israel's enemy through stealth and subversion. I for one find this extremely objectionable.

Israel has always been a friend and ally of Great Britain in a largely hostile world, and reactionary organisations such as the PSC that seek to subvert that relationship are frankly traitors.

There's a non-Jewish man-on-the-street view. Stick it in your pipe and smoke it, Zair.


Jonathan Hoffman

15 September, 2010 - 13:55

Rate this:

0 points

Statement by Ambassador Ron Prosor:

“This appalling decision speaks volumes about the calibre of those who voted for it. Whilst many around the world are helping to create an environment for peace, some in the TUC prefer to create a noisy distraction. These people contrast sharply with those responsible leaders, who at that very same time, were offering hope to the people of the Middle East. This resolution, in comparison, is hopeless, in both senses of the word.”


amber

15 September, 2010 - 22:39

Rate this:

1 point

I see zair - and the fact that Israel is held to different standards than any other country on earth has nothing to do with Jew hatred of course...

When will the Arabs sit up and listen, and give up on the idea of annihilating the Jewish state? What boycott do you support to achieve that end?

Jew hater.


zair

16 September, 2010 - 08:56

Rate this:

0 points

Yes Israel is held to different standards, very low and lenient ones.

I will not even attempt to address your last comment, it sounds like the rantings of a deranged banshee.


amber

16 September, 2010 - 10:28

Rate this:

1 point

zair, if you think the world is lenient towards Israel, but hard on Fatah, Hamas, Hizbollah, Saudi Arabia, North Korea, Suda, Libya, Syria, Iran, China, Zimbabwe and Turkey - then you are living in an antisemitic fantasy...but then you clearly are.


mattpryor

16 September, 2010 - 10:45

Rate this:

0 points

By the way Haaretz have picked this up now.

How long before Israelis start boycotting British goods?

Nice one TUC.


yankeeuxb

16 September, 2010 - 14:30

Rate this:

1 point

The boycott movement played an important part in ending Apartheid in South Africa. Not necessarily because it crippled the S. African economy but because it made people aware of the regime in S. Africa.

The same effect is happening now vis a vis Israel. Dockers, supermarkets, shoppers, local government procurement officers are all aware and sensitive to the BDS movement.

People are increasingly more aware of the shocking cruelty inflicted upon the Palestinians. There is no need for it either. That is what shocks the world so much. It seems as if israel takes pleasure in subjugating and humiliating (see facebook) an occupied people.

The excellent work of the TUC will help to spread the message.


Jonathan Hoffman

16 September, 2010 - 15:33

Rate this:

0 points

@yankeeuxb

Yeah, right. Israeli Arab women get the best education in the Middle East. Black women under apartheid got hardly any education. But of course the Apartheid comparison is fitting. What a clever boy.

The TUC Barons wanted to find a scapegoat to divert attention from their failure to do anything to improve the chances of their members keeping their jobs. As usual Israel was the scapegoat.

Go on, trash Israeli goods in a Tesco's supermarket if it makes you happy. That's about your moronic level. Then try getting a life.


yankeeuxb

16 September, 2010 - 15:58

Rate this:

1 point

Education spending in Israel on Jewish children is three times that as spent on Arab children. That's Apartheid.

The trades union members voted for the motion, not the 'barons'.

The good news about this motion is that it will gather headlines around the world. This will further bring people's attention to the situation under which the Palestinians are living. More awareness of the occupation will help the Palestinians with their freedom. Two states, free and secure.


Jonathan Hoffman

16 September, 2010 - 17:37

Rate this:

0 points

http://www.thejc.com/blogpost/the-barons-an-everyday-story-struggle-work...

"Education spending in Israel on Jewish children is three times that as spent on Arab children"

Sorry but you cannot get away with assertions like that without documenting them - you have been proved wrong too many times, it's like the little boy who cried "wolf"


Yvetta

16 September, 2010 - 20:17

Rate this:

1 point

Where's Uncle Tom these days?


amber

17 September, 2010 - 13:57

Rate this:

1 point

yankeeuxb, from where do you get that figure? Hamas?

How much is spent on the education of Jews in the Arab world?

POST A COMMENT

You must be logged in to post a comment.