Stop bashing Israel for helping Haitians, not Gazans

By Miriam Shaviv
January 22, 2010

Some people, it seems, cannot let Israel do anything good and just leave it at that. Any good deed by Israel must be turned into ammunition against it – used to condemn Israel for not being absolutely perfect.I am referring, of course, to Israel’s selfless aid to the devastated people of Haiti, and the rash of op-eds which have cropped up asking why Israel has not extended similar aid to the people of Gaza. Jerusalem Post columnist Larry Derfner explains, for example, how proud he is of Israel’s actions in Haiti, and then asks:

When will this big-hearted nation stop being heartless to the people in Gaza?

Seth Freedman, over at the Guardian, self-righteously opines that,

It is a damning indictment of Israel that it is prepared only to come to the aid of those who fit certain political criteria, rather than that of every victim crying out for intervention.

And Akiva Eldar at Haaretz, who kicked off this trend, believes that

Even the images of our excellent doctors in Haiti cannot blur our ugly face in the Strip.

So, a few points.

1. Israel – like every other country – does not have an obligation to help any other nation. It has only an obligation to defend and protect the lives, and interests, of its own citizens. Any aid it does extend (and in fact, Israel has offered humanitarian aid to 140 countries since 1958, some of which do not even have diplomatic relations with Israel and some of which would not even accept any goods with any Israeli markings on them) is a bonus, and does not make it responsible for “every victim crying out for intervention”.

 2. Some might argue that Israel is, in fact, responsible for the suffering in Gaza and as such does owe it special help. They are wrong. The people responsible for the suffering in Gaza are their own leaders, who could lay down their weapons, free Gilad Shalit, stop educating their Gaza people to hate Jews – and gain open borders, a state and a thriving economy immediately. Israel’s Operation Cast Lead and its decision to close its border with Gaza were correct and just. Again, Israel’s first obligation is to look after its own citizens and residents – not the Palestinian ones (though – to its eternal credit - it went out of its way, during the war, to minimise harm to innocents).

3. There are, in fact, very good reasons why the Palestinians in Gaza should be the last people on earth to whom Israel offers aid. The fact is that the Hamas government has effectively declared war on Israel, a war which – according to its own charter – it does not intend to abandon until Israel is destroyed completely. This is not theoretical: it has launched thousands of missiles at Israel and is building up an enormous arsenal for future use. Asking Israel to extend aid to the people of this regime comes from Christian places – it is asking Israel to turn the other cheek. Is there another country that would be condemned for not helping the people of a state that attacks it? Has anyone, incidentally, asked the Americans to extend aid deep in Taliban country? Perhaps they should build homes for the children of bin Laden’s entourage – after all, they are innocent children living in caves?

4. All that said, I firmly believe that the majority of Israelis harbour no deep-seated hatred of Palestinians and that if the Palestinians did agree to end the conflict, Israel and Israelis would show the same generosity to them that they have shown to the Haitians - just as they immediately returned to doing business with, and visiting, Palestinian areas in the West Bank between the two intifadas. Indeed, the fact is that Israel has already extended plenty of aid to the people of Gaza. Many Gazans have been treated, for example, in Israeli hospitals. Even during the last war with Gaza, Israel opened a field hospital on the border to treat Gazans. To me, this is the ultimate proof of Israel’s good character. It had no obligation to these people, with whom it was at war, and yet it treated them nonetheless. To me this is not just good, it is angelic. Israel, I’m proud of you.


Jonathan Hoffman

Fri, 01/22/2010 - 16:23

Rate this:

0 points

I agree with all this

But it was the person who sent out that crass email 'Israel's Disproportionate Response' who opened the floodgates for all those Gaza/Haiti comparisons ....

moshetzarfati2 (not verified)

Fri, 01/22/2010 - 17:18

Rate this:

0 points

Eldar, Derfner and Freedman, as well as others were quite right to point this out. More often than not, Israel and its ultra-supporters use this humanitarian aid as a PR job and not as some altruistic endeavour.


Fri, 01/22/2010 - 18:26

Rate this:

0 points

I agree also. One thing that puzzles me is this insistence that Israel has done nothing to help the Palestinians. Douglas Carswell's blog post, Why the British left hates Israel, lists a number of ways in which Israel has benefited Palestinians - ways we all know of course, such as common law, women's rights, schools, irrigation, modern hospitals and medicine and so on; all of them things that peaceful, law-abiding Arab/Muslim citizens of Israel have every much as right to access as her Jewish citizens do. Interesting how the British left were, to a large extent, sympathetic to the IRA's campaign of terror - it seems many of us (I count myself as a leftie, albeit a pro-Israeli one) have such a romantic attachment to the idealised "freedom fighter" and "armed revolution" (it pains me to say it, but I was supportive of the Red Army Faction as a youth) that we sometimes choose to ignore facts.


Sat, 01/23/2010 - 16:25

Rate this:

0 points

So very true, Miriam, so very true. Many thanks for this fine commentary; there are clearly no depths to which Israel's denigrators will not stoop in their quest for the little Jewish States's delegitimisation and destruction. Israel's selfless heroism in this should be lauded full stop/period.
The anti-Israel hate-mongers never waste an opportunity ... clearly, Israel is "The Jew among the Nations". I wonder what the great Herzl would have made of it all.

Trevor Fox

Sat, 01/23/2010 - 21:03

Rate this:

0 points

Israeli rescue and medical personnel did a fine and proud job in Haiti. Leave it at that.

The Haiti earthquake should not be used as a reason to bash the Israel bashers. This is totally out of order.

Miriam Shaviv

Sun, 01/24/2010 - 10:54

Rate this:

0 points

You mean, 'the Haiti earthquake should not be used as a reason to bash Israel' - right???

Trevor Fox

Sun, 01/24/2010 - 15:15

Rate this:

0 points

No, I mean the Haiti tragedy should not be used as a reason to bash Israel's bashers. Israel's bashers may be cynical about Israeli aid but Israel did what it had to do in Haiti and did it well. That assistance does not have to be used to relate to other issues either by Israel's bashers or supporters.

In the body of your article Israel is mentioned about 18 times and Haiti is mentioned 4 times. Your article is meant to refer to the devastation of Haiti.

There, I've mentioned Haiti and Israel an equal number of times.


Wed, 01/27/2010 - 09:20

Rate this:

0 points

Please all watch this. I hope that most of you condemn it,


You must be logged in to post a comment.