School entry conundrum

By Simon Rocker
October 26, 2010

Hardly a week goes by without us receiving an inquiry about Jewish school admissions.

It’s almost a year and a half since the courts forced Jewish schools to introduce new entry rules based on religious practice – and parents are still grappling with the consequences.

This week a letter came in from some anonymous “concerned parents” wondering if it was illegal for schools to use synagogue membership as one of their entry criteria.

The courts ruled last year that schools could not accept children simply on the basis of whether their parents were Jewish. This was because Jews are legally classified as an ethnic group and so to admit children according to parental descent falls foul of the laws against racial discrimination.

But faith schools are allowed to admit children on the basis of religious practice or belief.

The United Synagogue, after taking legal advice, told schools under its denominational umbrella that they could not choose pupils simply on the basis of whether their family belonged to a synagogue or not.

According to the US website: “In order to be a member of a synagogue, one has to pay a fee and for Orthodox synagogue membership, one has to be halachically Jewish. Following the Supreme Court judgment, we have been advised that synagogue membership cannot be used as an admission criterion.”

Other schools beg to differ and do use synagogue membership.

So who is right? It would probably take another court case to arrive at a definitive view…



Tue, 10/26/2010 - 18:35

Rate this:

0 points

Simon you are wasting the wear and tear on your keyboard. No one is interested in the British jewish experience its all about Israel did you not know that ?


Tue, 11/02/2010 - 21:39

Rate this:

2 points

Have to disagree with you.
Whats going on in your own backyard is just as important. I dont know about you but I live in this country not Israel.


Tue, 11/02/2010 - 21:41

Rate this:

0 points

You are quite right, TheBrit. But there are some here for whom Israel is the be all and end all of their Judaism. In fact, it probably replaces their Judaism and has become their religion.

Anthony Posner

Tue, 11/02/2010 - 21:48

Rate this:

0 points

Sorry to interrupt this civilized discussion.

But is it "The Brit" or Thebrit"

Anthony Posner

Tue, 11/02/2010 - 21:52

Rate this:

0 points


Are you really suggesting that for some Jews, Zionism is some sort of religion? Now that is quite incredible. What evidence do you have for such wild assertions?

Do some Jews actually pray towards Jerusdalem??

Surely you are making all this up as you go along.


You must be logged in to post a comment.