Giving Hamas a chance


By Miriam Shaviv
June 7, 2010
Share

Nick Cohen, in the Guardian, has written an impassioned and generally excellent piece on the real reason the Arab states attack Israel, and the effect this has on Western liberals. Read it in its entirety.

Towards the end, however,  he makes the following disturbing suggestion:

Israelis are not being irrational [about fears of Hamas re-arming if the blockade is relaxed - MS]. The same fears persuade the Egyptian government to blockade Gaza from the south, although we rarely hear about that. But the way to handle hypocrites is not to say as Israelis do that "the world will condemn us whatever policy we follow" but to call their bluff. If Israel were to relax the import restrictions and Hamas were to rearm, reasonable opinion, including reasonable Palestinian opinion, would see it for what it would be: a declaration of war.

This is extremely naive. Look what happened in southern Lebanon after the second Lebanon war in 2006. The international community fully guaranteed that Hizbollah would not be allowed to re-arm with UN Security Council resolution 1701. Did that stop Hizbollah building an even larger stockpile of illegal weapons than before? No. Did anyone see that as a declaration of war? No. The West has turned a blind eye, preferring an easy life to fulfilling its difficult commitments.

The result: growing chatter in Israel about the increasing likelihood of another northern war.

The idea that the international community would behave any differently if the Gaza blockade was relaxed is frankly laughable.

In any case, who exactly is 'reasonable opinion'? And do they have any influence? So far I haven't seen much evidence....

COMMENTS

Blacklisted Dictator

Mon, 06/07/2010 - 12:22

Rate this:

0 points

Miriam,

Yes, Cohen's sonclusion is meshuggah. It is beyond naive.

However, I have spotted something else that is naive. Cohen writes:

"Put like this, the behaviour of European liberals seems more reprehensible than ever. Instead of confronting or even arguing with the anti-liberal forces that are terrorising much of the Middle East and Asia, they appease them and offer them Israel as a placatory gesture, when Israel is not theirs to give away."

However, such "Europen liberals" are not liberals. They are confused anti-semitic Marxists, who use "liberal" as camouflage. Wouldn't you, in their circumstances?

(But when you get a moment, please address the points that I raised in your previous blog.)

POST A COMMENT

You must be logged in to post a comment.

MIRIAM SHAVIV ON TWITTER

    LATEST COMMENTS