British-Israel crisis: Timing is everything


By Miriam Shaviv
March 23, 2010
Share

The speculation that an Israeli diplomat is to be expelled from the UK (or perhaps has been expelled already?) has taken everyone by surprise.

When the passports scandal first broke, Mr Prosor was invited to the Foreign Office - and emerged, all smiles. The Brits sent investigators to Israel interview the British nationals whose identities were allegedly stolen - but this was widely assumed to be a formality (and perhaps a fun perk for the investigators). That seemed to be the end of the affair, from the British point of view.

The question is, then, why this drastic British action now - weeks after the scandal seemed to have blown over?  Miliband could have made  his anti-Israeli statement at any point and would have chosen his moment carefully. What is the significance of the timing?

One strong possibility is that the British move is connected to the mammoth row between the Israelis and Americans over building in east (actually, northeast) Jerusalem last week. Political observers will want to know: Have the Americans asked their British counterparts to apply pressure on the Israelis - to squeeze Bibi just a little more, to make it a bit harder for him to resist the Americans' demands? (Even if it turns out this was not the intention, it will surely be the result).

It also seems extraordinary for Mr Miliband to address parliament on this issue at the very moment - 15.30 - when he was due to be the guest of honour at the Israeli embassy's housewarming party. When it was first announced that he would be attending the reception - a week after the Dubai passport scandal erupted - it was interpreted as a strong sign that the Brits wanted to keep things friendly with the Israelis. For Miliband to withdraw, now, in order to issue a strong statement against Israel instead, cannot be a coincidence; what a slap in the face.

COMMENTS

moshetzarfati2

23 March, 2010 - 11:54

Rate this:

0 points

Didn't Maggie T also expel "a senior Israeli diplomat" after a similar case? Was that because
of the timing of an embassy housewarming or a US row over housing in the occupied territories? No, didn't think so. Anyway it means there will be more Ferrero Rochard at the do this afternoon. See you there?


Miriam Shaviv

23 March, 2010 - 12:01

Rate this:

0 points

Why, are you going (from Aberdeen)? How will I recognise you?


moshetzarfati2

23 March, 2010 - 12:04

Rate this:

0 points

I'll be wearing a red carnation and carrying the Financial Tiimes


Jonathan Hoffman

23 March, 2010 - 14:00

Rate this:

0 points

Of course the timing has nothing to do with relegating to the inside pages the story about three senior Labour MPs being expelled from the PLP ....


mattpryor

23 March, 2010 - 14:19

Rate this:

0 points

Good point Jonathan, hadn't thought about that.

They know that the people they upset probably won't be voting Labour anyway, and probably won't make a fuss because we don't want to make ourselves targets of the kinds of extremists that like to set alight to BBC buildings, riot, attack police, beat up Jews in broad daylight, etc.

Cowardly, hypocritical, treacherous bastards.


mattpryor

23 March, 2010 - 14:21

Rate this:

0 points

And this could be a perfect opportunity for the Tories to act like a proper opposition and hold the treacherous, cowardly, hypocritical Labour government to account for their betrayal.

Will they?


moshetzarfati2

23 March, 2010 - 14:31

Rate this:

0 points

Yep, thought so. Timing had nothing to do with this. Thatcher did it first in 1986 when the UK hoofed out the Mossad rep, Arye Regev, also after a passport scam. She also sus[ended all ties with Israeli intelligence. Not an oxymoron in this case. Nothing to do with housewarmings, discredited Labour MPs, spats with the US over illegal building in Jerusalem or any other lame excuse.
Former Israeli ambassador to the UK, Zvi Stauber, told Ynet that London has no interest in blowing up the affair, but "They had to do something. There is also a link with the general feeling that 'Israel is not immune'."
"If the US, which is the sign of what is permitted and what is forbidden in relations with Israel, is ready to pull up its sleeves in dealing with Israel, other states can too," he continued. "The issue of passport use is not central in the UK electorate, but I have no doubt that Labor and Prime Minister Gordon Brown were under internal pressure to do something. On the other hand, I think Britain has a relatively supportive government regarding Israel."


John Gold

24 March, 2010 - 01:50

Rate this:

0 points

Why do so many people (on this site) - strain at a knat and swallow a camel?
Every time someone accuses Israel of wrongdoing, or major gaffs in it's foreign policy or it's diplomacy skills (or lack there of) - it's because the Brits 'want to hide a news story', or 'Clinton wants revenge on Monica Lewinsky'.....

Read it straight for what it is - Israel is messing things up in their own country and generally seem to have an arrogant attitude towards others (metaphorically sticking two fingers up at the world), and we're not even talking about their (many enemies) or even neutrals - but their 'supposed' allies!

Read it for what it is: Israel says it wants a peace settlement and it's actions, on the very day of America's visit, start building on Palestinian land?
Either be honest and say you have no intention of having peace talks - and sharing the land - or show integrity and do as you say (and don't mock the powerful that protect you).

Britain - Israel have shown no remorse, or sign of an apology and have denied the whole thing - are Israel trying to mock the British intelligence service?

As for miriam saying it's a slap in the face for not attending some 'Israeli housewarming party' - it';s only a return for "...adding insult to injury”. as Milliband put it.

I'm anticipating the usual someone ready to call him a Jewish anti- semite, no doubt in order to deflect one's own (or the state of Israel's) guilt and yet again blame the world instead of 'looking at the man in the mirror'.....

POST A COMMENT

You must be logged in to post a comment.