A welcome Israeli initiative


By telegramsam
October 13, 2010
Share

According to this report in Maariv (and again, I'm sorry but there is no translation yet), a group of Jewish leaders is meeting in Jerusalem under the auspices of the Jewish People Policy Planning Institute, which I think is a Jewish Agency off-shoot.
Britain is represented by Sir Ronald Cohen, the founder of Hedge Fund Apax, while other participants come from across the diaspora political spectrum, including the former US presidential adviser Elliott Abrams; Malcolm Hoenlein of the Conference of Presidents of the Major American Jewish Organizations; former U.S. ambassador to Israel Daniel Kurtzer; the head of the Anti-Defamation League, Abraham Foxman; the senior vice president of Bna'i B'rith International, Daniel Mariaschin; Pierre Besnainou, a leading figure of the Jewish community in France.
The team will present its findings to Binyamin Netanyahu and Shmon Peres.
Avinoam Bar-Yosef, the head of the JPPPI, said:"Currently there is a political process that is expected to focus on the core issues, Jerusalem, access to the holy sites, the character of the State of Israel. These are issues that even if the Jewish people in the Diaspora do not participate in the discussions, it affects their future and [they] must express an opinion and make sure that it is being heard."
So this puts lie to the claim by some that if you don't live in Israel, you must not comment on, and especially not criticise, Israeli policies.

COMMENTS

Jabotinsky

13 October, 2010 - 09:26

Rate this:

1 point

"So this puts lie to the claim by some that if you don't live in Israel, you must not comment on, and especially not criticise, Israeli policies."

There is all the difference in the world between criticism and deligitimisation. You engage in the former and not the latter, and, I might add, in the utterly obsessive fashion that is so typical of those who hate the Jewish state. You people may have adopted new tactics, but your ideology is very old.

For my part, as a citizen of a country that collaborated in the Holocaust and also acted in a manner in post-war Palestine that would have done credit to the SS, I feel uncomfortable even criticising Israel.

Joshua18

P.S. Re my "banning" you might want to check out Pollard's post once again.


mattpryor

13 October, 2010 - 09:39

Rate this:

0 points

Welcome back Joshua.


telegramsam

13 October, 2010 - 09:40

Rate this:

0 points

Hello, Joshua18, gotta new name? By the way, did you know that Jabo advocated a binational state in which the Jews and the non-Jews would share national leadership? You know, a Jewish PM and a non-Jewish President and vice versa. No, I am not delegitimising Israel - although I can see where you might think that anyone who criticises certain self-defeating policies believes that.I am an advocate of the two-state solution (like Bibi, actually), where a Palestinian state and a Jewish state can live side-by-side. That's actually Israeli government policy, so how can that be delegitimising?

POST A COMMENT

You must be logged in to post a comment.